Pastries

Bob Andy Pie

United States

A cinnamon-spiced milk-and-egg custard pie associated with Midwestern Amish communities, baked in a pastry shell. Some recipes also include cloves.

PastriesDessertUncommon
Bob Andy Pie sticker illustration

A closer look

What to look for.

A smooth, gently set custard with a clear cinnamon aroma and a browned surface in a pastry shell. The filling should be creamy rather than molasses-dark or treacly.

Geographic connections

Places and
traditions.

Explore the places connected to Bob Andy Pie, from possible origins to local traditions.

Associated with

United States

A cultural connection; not necessarily its birthplace

Explore

Keep exploring

More foods to discover.

More like this →